Both.news
Story AnalysisNews report

Hacked records show 400,000 Russians killed in war on Ukraine

The material, obtained by a Belarusian pro-opposition group and a Ukrainian hacker operation, gives rare insight into the war’s true cost for Russia.

japantimes.co.jpPublished Analyzed on November 9, 2026

This page is Both News's AI analysis of the article, not the article itself. Read the full story on the publisher's site.

Our verdict

Political lean

Center
◀ Left 10Center10 Right ▶

0 = center. The further from 0, the stronger the lean (max 10).

Reporting balance

80
Well balanced
80 / 100

How complete and even-handed the reporting is — separate from which side it leans.

This is a balanced accountability news report centered on leaked civil records indicating about 400,000 Russian war deaths, with unusually thorough caveats and cross-checks. Its main strength is transparent treatment of uncertainty, including undercount risks, registration lags, and competing estimates from Russian, Ukrainian, and independent sources. Readers should keep in mind that authenticity was assessed by consistency checks rather than cryptographic proof and that Russia disputes any compromise of the database.

Why this lean
No US left/right framing, sourcing, or word choices push toward either US party; the story documents Russian military deaths using hacker-provided data while including Russian official denials, Ukrainian loss figures, western intelligence, and independent Russian trackers.
Framing
The story is told from the angle of independent accountability reporting: the central question is what hacked civil death records reveal about Russia's true war death toll despite Kremlin secrecy.

Key Findings

  1. 1Headline-level figure of about 400,000 is presented as a rounded version of 392,700 explicitly war-linked certificates, not as a precise count, with repeated warnings that the dataset almost certainly understates deaths due to missing, unidentified, delayed, or miscategorized records.
  2. 2Transparency about verification is a strength: the article states cryptographic authenticity could not be independently proved, then cites metadata consistency, no fabrication indicators, and approximate 0.1% and 0.2% differences in 2021-2022 totals and about 1% higher in 2023 versus official Rosstat figures.
  3. 3Inconvenient context is included: Ukrainian losses via Zelenskyy's at least 55,000 figure, Ukraine's much higher 1.6 million Russian dead-plus-seriously-injured claim, registration lags, and patchier records from mid-2024 with nearly half of war deaths missing home region.
  4. 4Russian official position is represented through Rosstat's compromise denial and noted non-response on losses, plus context that Rosstat stopped publishing many statistics after 2022 and that the 2022 partial-mobilization decree was never formally revoked.
  5. 5Demographic detail supports the toll without overstating precision: examples include over 12,600 deaths among men 50-59 in first half of 2025 versus 146 in first half of 2022, about two-thirds of deaths among men 18-29 war-related, and about one-third versus about one in 10 regional disparity between remote Siberian republics and Moscow/St. Petersburg.

Who gets a voice

  • Silent Crow and Cyber Partisans
    Ukrainian hacker operation and Belarusian pro-opposition group that obtained the data
    Source claiming large Russian losses and successful Rosstat breachMain voice
  • Rosstat
    Russian statistics agency
    Official Russian position denying database compromiseMain voice
  • Independent Russian outlet Mediazona with BBC Russian Service
    Independent casualty trackers
    Corroborating high Russian death toll by nameMain voice
  • Mediazona and Meduza
    Independent outlets using probate registry
    Separate estimate of about 352,000 deathsMinor voice
  • Volodymyr Zelenskyy
    President of Ukraine
    Ukrainian official acknowledgement of at least 55,000 Ukrainian soldiers killedMinor voice
  • Ukraine's General Staff, and Ukraine and western intelligence agencies
    Ukrainian and western official estimators
    Higher Russian loss claims including 1.6 million dead and seriously injured and 54,000 lost in OctoberMinor voice
  • People familiar with the situation in the Russian military
    Anonymous sources
    Assessment that about 400,000 Russian war deaths is realisticMinor voice

Dimension Breakdown

Source Diversity8/10

Cites hackers, Rosstat, anonymous military-informed sources, Mediazona/BBC, Mediazona/Meduza, Zelenskyy, Ukraine General Staff, and Ukraine plus western intelligence; Russian side is limited to Rosstat denial and noted non-response.

Language Neutrality8/10

Largely plain and attributed; interpretive phrases like “gone to great lengths to avoid acknowledging” and “breaking Kyiv’s morale” are analytical but not partisan labels or emotive slurs.

Data Balance9/10

Gives sourced numbers with checks: 392,700 explicit war links, 450,000 Silent Crow estimate, 285,881 named, 352,000 probate estimate, 1.6 million Ukrainian claim, plus 0.1%, 0.2% and 1% consistency checks against 2021-2023 official totals.

Perspective Completeness8/10

Hears Russian state position, Ukrainian official figures, and independent Russian trackers; lacks direct on-record Russian military comment, but notes Russia has not published casualties since early months.

Headline Accuracy8/10

Full headline was not supplied beyond the URL slug about hacked Russian deaths in Ukraine, which aligns with the body's about 400,000 figure and its stated caveats.

Context Sufficiency8/10

Explains invasion start date, 2015 secrecy rule, halt to Rosstat publication, registration lags, age and regional breakdowns, recruitment pressure, and Abu Dhabi ceasefire talks.

Missing Perspectives

  • On-record Russian Defence Ministry or Kremlin response on the casualty figure itself, beyond Rosstat's denial about the hack; matters because the central claim concerns state secrecy about losses.
  • Named independent data-forensic reviewer or methodology detail for the export check; matters because authenticity explicitly could not be cryptographically proved.
  • Direct perspective of bereaved families, registrars, or frontline medical staff on delays and missing records; matters for interpreting lags and undercount claims.

Key Facts

  • According to the article, almost 392,700 death certificates between Feb. 24, 2022 and late August 2026 explicitly link fatalities to the war via coding or terms like “military operation,” “shelling” or “drones.”
  • According to Silent Crow, its calculation including noncombat-related fatalities is about 450,000.
  • According to the article, Putin made military losses in peacetime during special operations or war a state secret as far back as 2015, and Russia has not provided casualty figures since early months of the invasion.
  • According to Rosstat, cited in the article, it detected targeted cyberattacks Oct. 29 to Nov. 1 but found no evidence databases were compromised or confidential information leaked.
  • According to Zelenskyy in February to French media, at least 55,000 Ukrainian soldiers had been killed, with many missing.
  • According to Ukraine and western intelligence agencies, Russia lost a record 54,000 troops killed or seriously wounded in October.
  • According to Mediazona and BBC Russian Service tracking, 285,881 Russian deaths were identified by name as of this month; Mediazona and Meduza separately estimated about 352,000 through December 2025 from the probate registry.
Read the original articlejapantimes.co.jp · japantimes.co.jp

Like reading the news this way?

Get the top stories as fact-based reports and bias analyses, from left, center and right. Free, unsubscribe any time.

Outlets we read and analyze every day

61 outlets from the left, center and right. Logos belong to their publishers; we're not affiliated with them.

Every outlet, with ownership and lean →